etd AT Indian Institute of Science >
Division of Biological Sciences >
Molecular Biophysics Unit (mbu) >
Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:
|Title: ||Energetics Of Protein-Carbohydrate Recognition|
|Authors: ||Swaminathan, C P|
|Advisors: ||Surolia, Avadhesha|
|Submitted Date: ||Jan-2000|
|Publisher: ||Indian Institute of Science|
|Abstract: ||The work embodied in this thesis pertains to an attempt to understand better, the molecular basis of protein-carbohydrate recognition. For this purpose a systematic study was undertaken, not only of the energetics of lectin-sugar interactions, which serve as molecular recognition prototype of protein-carbohydrate interactions, but also of the complex effects of solvent water molecules surrounding both the species in solution state. The systems chosen for investigation include the specific recognition of sugars by lectins from diverse families, leguminosae and moraceae. The following salient aspects of the molecular recognition process constitute the focus of this thesis:
• Effect of site specifically modified, deoxy-, fluorodeoxy-, or methoxy- substituted
D-galactopyranoside binding to lectins. Isothermal titration calorimetric (ITC)
investigations of the binding of these sugars to a model lectin permitted the correct
prediction of the architecture of the primary binding site in the absence of x-ray
crystal or NMR structure of the combining site (Ref. 7). The study provided the
only unambiguous means of a site specific mapping of the hydrogen-bond donor-
acceptor relationship of the monosaccharide within the primary combining site of
• Novel features of lectin-sugar recognition. Molecular interactions and forces
contributing to the stabilization of the saccharides in the primary combining site of
lectins. Binding of site specifically modified fluoro- substituted D-
galactopyranosides to WBA I led to the demonstration of the involvement of C-
F««»H-0 hydrogen bonds in stabilizing the saccharide within the combining site
of lectin (Ref. 7). Implication of the novel C-H«**O hydrogen bonds at the
specificity determining C-4 position in enabling the methoxy- substituted D-
galactopyranoside to be stabilized within the primary binding site of galactose
specific lectins WBA I and jacalin.
• Development of a novel coupled osmotic-thermodynamic approach for
investigating the role of water molecules in determining the specificity of lectin-
sugar interactions. The results obtained led to the first direct demonstration of a
differential uptake of water molecules accompanying the specific process of
recognition of sugars by lectins (Ref 2)
• On the origin of enthalpy-entropy compensation, a ubiquitous phenomenon accompanying the thermodynamics of several ligand binding reactions in aqueous solutions in general and the molecular recognition involving all known lectin-sugar interactions, in particular. The results provide the first unequivocal solution state proof of water reorganization as the source of enthalpy-entropy compensation (Ref 3). A new diagnostic test of a true osmotic effect in molecular recognition phenomena was proposed (Ref. 2) and validated (Ref. 3).
As an introduction, Chapter 1 is a comprehensive review of literature that touches upon the diverse properties of lectins and our present understanding of their multifarious roles and applications, which has led to their christening, perhaps appropriately, as molecules that mediate the 'social' functions of cells and tissues. Although a challenge it is still, to decipher the "glycocode", it is apparent that the fundamental basis of the recognition function of lectin-sugar interactions is the initial specific binding of the saccharide molecule by the globular proteinaceous lectin molecule. It is imperative, therefore, that an incisive investigation of the origin of specificity of the binding reaction as well as the solvent effects influencing both the interacting species be undertaken for a better understanding of the complete molecular recognition process. Towards this end is introduced in Chapter 1 our present understanding of the results on lectin-sugar interactions from two complementary approaches viz structural, including X-ray crystallography and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, as well as thermodvnamic ones, which have provided important information on the architecture of the combining sites, the dynamic modes of saccharide recognition and forces involved therein. Despite a detailed knowledge available from such methods, a structure-energetics correlation has persisted as a current challenge of the field. Towards achieving this goal, studies on the energetics of the recognition of sugars by lectins were undertaken, with an aim to better understand the origin of specificity of lectin-sugar interactions. This thesis attempts to provide new insights on some of the possible lacunae precluding structure-energetics correlation and suggests ways to overcome them.
Chapter 2 deals with ITC investigation of the effect of deoxy-, fluorodeoxy-,
and methoxy- substitutions on the binding of monosaccharides to the primary combining site of the lectin WBA I isolated from the mature seeds of the leguminosae family member Psophocarpus tetragonolobus as well as the moraceae lectin jacalin. These studies provide valuable information on the hydrogen-bond donor-acceptor relationships within the combining site of the lectins wherein the sugar molecule is liganded with the amino-acid residues of the lectin. This study is relevant for understanding the origin of specificity of monosaccharide binding within the primary combining site of the lectins. It has recently become apparent that there is a predisposition in three-dimensional space, of the donor-acceptor pairs within the sugar binding site of the lectins. Hence there appears to be a stereochemical basis of distinguishing the recognition of the donor group vis-a-vis that of the acceptor group and that their spatial disposition determines the specificity of the saccharide recognition. Unambiguous assignment of which of the groups within the hydrogen bonded pairs is a donor and which one is the acceptor assumes greater importance. The ITC measurements of the binding of deoxy-, flurodeoxy-and methoxy-derivatives of D-galactopyranoside (oc-D-Gal) to the basic lectin from winged bean Psophocarpus tetragonolobus, WBA I revealed that each of the ligands bind to WBA I with the same stoichiometry of one per subunit (29 kDa) of WBA I. The binding enthalpies for various derivatives were essentially independent of temperature and showed complementary changes with respect to binding entropies. Replacement of the hydroxyl group by fluorine or hydrogen on C3 and C4 of the galactopyranoside eliminated their binding to the lectin, consistent with C3-OH and C4-OH acting as hydrogen bond donors. The affinity for C2 derivatives of galactose decreased in the order: GalNAc>2MeOGal>2FGal=Gal>2HGal which suggests that both polar and non-polar residues surround the C2 locus of galactose, consistent with the observed high affinity of WBA I towards GalNAc, where the acetamido group at C2 position is probably stabilized by both non-polar interactions with the methyl-group and polar interactions with the carbonyl group. The binding of C6 derivatives followed the order: Gal>6FGal>D-Fuc»6MeOGal=L-Ara indicating the presence of favourable polar interactions with a hydrogen bond donor in the vicinity. Based on these results
the hydrogen bond donor-acceptor relationship of the complexation of methyl-a-D-galactopyranoside with the primary combining site of WBA I was proposed (Ref. /), which was subsequently validated by the crystal structure of methyl-a-D-galactopyranoside complexed with WBA I. This chapter also describes the results from ITC studies on the binding of monosaccharides and disaccharides to the lectin jacalin isolated from the mature seeds of the moraceae family member Artocarpus integrifolia. The novel observation about the existence of C-F*«*H-0 and C-H**»O hydrogen bonds in lectin-sugar interactions is also discussed in this chapter.
Chapter 3 is a description of the detailed investigation on the role of water molecules in influencing the energetics of lectin-sugar recognition. A novel coupled osmotic-thermodynamic approach was developed to dissect the role of water molecules in determining the recognition of the sugars by lectins. For this purpose, the model system of mannotriose-concanavalin A was used because atomic level structural information on these complexes were available. The work described in this chapter, is the first solution state evidence for the role of water molecules in the specific interaction of carbohydrates with a legume lectin, concanavalin A (Con A) (Ref. 2). Sugar binding to Con A was accompanied by linear changes in the logarithm of binding constants as a function of neutral osmolyte strength, and were described by well defined negative slopes characteristic for each sugar. As these changes were independent of the chemical nature of the osmolyte used, the results were rationalized in terms of a true osmotic effect. It was demonstrated that the specific recognition of the branched trimannoside (3,6-di-0-(a-D-mannopyranosyl)~a-D-mannopyranoside), the individual dimannosidic arms (3-<9-(a-D-mannopyranosyl)-a-D-mannopyranoside, and 6-0-(a-D-marmopyranosyl)-a-D-mannopyranoside) and the monomeric unit D-mannopyranoside by Con A was accompanied by differential uptake of water molecules; 1,3 and 5 respectively. We also observed a conservation of the compensatory behaviour of binding enthalpies and entropies in the presence as well as absence of osmolytes. This provided the first definitive evidence that water-reorganization plays a direct role in effecting the phenomenon of enthalpy-entropy compensation in protein-ligand interactions in general and lectin-sugar interactions
in particular, and that the specificity of lectin-sugar recognition is characterized by a differential uptake of water molecules.
Chapter 3 also describes the first experimental identification of the origin of enthalpy-entropy compensation (EEC), a ubiquitous phenomenon accompanying the thermodynamics of multifarious biomolecular recognition processes. By coupling direct microcalorimetry with osmotic stress technique, an experimental handle was devised to test the hypothesis that solvent reorganization could be the source of EEC. The results provided an unequivocal demonstration that an osmotic change in water activity alone, at the same temperature and pH, is sufficient to result in the conservation of EEC during the molecular recognition of specific ligands by macromolecules belonging to thermodynamically diverse and unrelated systems, a compelling evidence that the primary source of EEC in aqueous solutions is attributable to reorganization of solvent water molecules, thus validating the test for the role of water reorganization as a source of EEC (Ref. 3). This provides the first definitive evidence for the notion that there is a direct involvement of water molecules in originating the EEC effect. Despite the generality of the results it is urged that several systems be subjected to a vigorous application of the coupled osmotic-thermodynamic approach proposed herein before constituting it as a proof. Suffice to say, it is perhaps heartening that at last one has a handle to test the role of water molecules in effecting EEC in the solution state and appreciate the diverse roles played by water molecules in mediating molecular recognition reactions.
The proposal presented in Ref 2, that the strong isoequilibrium relationship of enthalpy with entropy during the recognition of saccharides by Con A studied under osmotic stress, be considered as diagnostic of a true osmotic effect was subsequently validated in a thermodynamically diverse and unrelated system of peptide recognition by monoclonal antibody, the results from which are discussed in an Appendix (A) to this thesis (Ref 4). That the stabilities of these lectins are not hampered in the presence of osmolytes was demonstrated using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) (Ref 2). During the course of these DSC studies, we discovered an unusual feature in an animal galectin. Despite possessing the legume lectin fold, the 14-kDa S-
type lectin exhibits multiple oligomeric states that are influenced profoundly by complementary ligands and surprisingly do not dissociate at the denaturation temperature. These results are discussed in an Appendix (B) to this thesis (Ref. 5).
The general discussion and conclusions drawn from this work are summarized in chapter 4. Briefly, the following salient conclusions can be drawn from the work presented in this thesis:
1. Unambiguous assignment of hydrogen-bond donor-acceptor relationship at
each of the hydroxyl group of the monosaccharide bound to the lectin belonging to
different families has been demonstrated (Refs. 1,6).
2. First report of novel hydrogen bonds in lectin-sugar interactions such as C-
F«MH-0 (Ref 1) and C-H^*O hydrogen bonds (Ref 6).
3. Unusual structural stabilities in a galectin with a fold similar to that in
legume lectins but with starkly different thermodynamic stabilities (Ref 5).
4. We have demonstrated for the first time in solution state, that water
molecules are involved in the specific recognition of sugars by concanavalin A (Ref
2). It appears that lectin-sugar recognition reactions are, in general, mediated by a net
uptake of water molecules during the binding process (Ref 7).
5. We have provided the first experimental demonstration that reorganization
of water molecules is the source of enthalpy-entropy compensation in molecular
recognition processes (Ref 3).
6. We provide evidence for another facet in the recognition of antigens by
antibodies, viz water release accompanying the binding reaction (Ref 4).
The studies reported in this thesis provide the foundation for embarking on a systematic study not only of the origin of specificity of lectin-sugar recognition but also of the complex roles that water molecules play in mediating these molecular recognition processes. These specific binding reactions wherein non-linear thermodynamics predominates and precludes a direct structure-energetics correlation emphasize the need to account for the effect of solvent water molecules in lectin-sugar interactions in particular and, without any overemphasis, in molecular recognition processes in general.|
|Appears in Collections:||Molecular Biophysics Unit (mbu)|
Items in etd@IISc are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.