
etd AT Indian Institute of Science >
Division of Mechanical Sciences >
Aerospace Engineering (aero) >
Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:
http://hdl.handle.net/2005/562

Title:  Structural Health Monitoring Of Composite Structures Using Magnetostrictive Sensors And Actuators 
Authors:  Ghosh, Debiprasad 
Advisors:  Gopalakrishnan, S 
Keywords:  Composite Structures Magnetostrictive Sensor Magnetostrictive Actuator Structural Health Monitoring Magnetostrictive Materials Composite Materials  Delamination Magnetostrictive Sensors Magnetostrictive Patches Inverse Problem Composite Beam Composite Laminate Coupled Analysis 
Submitted Date:  Jan2007 
Series/Report no.:  G20566 
Abstract:  Fiber reinforced composite materials are widely used in aerospace, mechanical, civil and other industries because of their high strengthtoweight and stiffnesstoweight ratios. However, composite structures are highly prone to impact damage. Possible types of defect or damage in composite include matrix cracking, fiber breakage, and delamination between plies. In addition, delamination in a laminated composite is usually invisible. It is very diffcult to detect it while the component is in service and this will eventually lead to catastrophic failure of the structure. Such damages may be caused by dropped tools
and ground handling equipments. Damage in a composite structure normally starts as a
tiny speckle and gradually grows with the increase in load to some degree. However, when such damage reaches a threshold level, serious accident can occur. Hence, it is important to have uptodate information on the integrity of the structure to ensure the safety and reliability of composite components, which require frequent inspections to identify and quantify damage that might have occurred even during manufacturing, transportation or
storage.
How to identify a damage using the obtained information from a damaged composite structure is one of the most pivotal research objectives. Various forms of structural damage cause variations in structural mechanical characteristics, and this property is extensively employed for damage detection. Existing traditional nondestructive inspection techniques utilize a variety of methods such as acoustic emission, Cscan, thermography, shearography and Moir interferometry etc. Each of these techniques is limited in accuracy
and applicability. Most of these methods require access to the structure.They also require a significant amount of equipment and expertise to perform inspection. The inspections are typically based on a schedule rather than based on the condition of the structure. Furthermore, the cost associated with these traditional nondestructive techniques can be rather prohibitive. Therefore, there is a need to develop a costeffective, inservice,
diagnostic system for monitoring structural integrity in composite structures.
Structural health monitoring techniques based on dynamic response is being used
for several years. Changes in lower natural frequencies and mode shapes with their special derivatives or stiffness/ exibility calculation from the measured displacement mode shapes are the most common parameters used in identification of damage. But the sensitivity of these parameters for incipient damage is not satisfactory. On the other hand, for in service structural health monitoring, direct use of structural response histories are more suitable. However, they are very few works reported in the literature on these aspects, especially
for composite structures, where higher order modes are the ones that get normally excited
due to the presence of flaws.
Due to the absence of suitable direct procedure, damage identification from response histories needs inverse mapping; like artificial neural network. But, the main diffculty in such mapping using whole response histories is its high dimensionality. Different general purpose dimension reduction procedures; like principle component analysis or indepen
dent component analysis are available in the literature. As these dimensionally reduced
spaces may loose the output uniqueness, which is an essential requirement for neural
network mapping, suitable algorithms for extraction of damage signature from these re
sponse histories are not available. Alternatively, fusion of trained networks for different partitioning of the damage space or different number of dimension reduction technique, can overcome this issue efficiently. In addition, coordination of different networks trained with different partitioning for training and testing samples, training algorithms, initial
conditions, learning and momentum rates, architectures and sequence of training etc., are some of the factors that improves the mapping efficiency of the networks.
The applications of smart materials have drawn much attention in aerospace, civil,
mechanical and even bioengineering. The emerging field of smart composite structures
offers the promise of truly integrated health and usage monitoring, where a structure can sense and adapt to their environment, loading conditions and operational requirements, and materials can selfrepair when damaged. The concept of structural health monitoring using smart materials relies on a network of sensors and actuators integrated with the structure. This area shows great promise as it will be possible to monitor the structural condition of a structure, throughout its service lifetime. Integrating intelligence into
the structures using such networks is an interesting field of research in recent years. Some materials that are being used for this purpose include piezoelectric, magnetostrictive and fiberoptic sensors. Structural health monitoring using, piezoelectric or fiberoptic sensors are available in the literature. However, very few works have been reported in the
literature on the use of magnetostrictive materials, especially for composite structures.
Non contact sensing and actuation with high coupling factor, along with other prop
erties such as large bandwidth and less voltage requirement, make magnetostrictive materials increasingly popular as potential candidates for sensors and actuators in structural health monitoring. Constitutive relationships of magnetostrictive material are represented through two equations, one for actuation and other for sensing, both of which are coupled through magnetomechanical coefficient. In existing finite element formulation, both the equations are decoupled assuming magnetic field as proportional to the applied current. This assumption neglects the stiffness contribution coming from the coupling between
mechanical and magnetic domains, which can cause the response to deviate from the time
response. In addition, due to different fabrication and curing difficulties, the actual properties of this material such as magnetomechanical coupling coefficient or elastic modulus, may differ from results measured at laboratory conditions. Hence, identification of the material properties of these embedded sensor and actuator are essential at their insitu condition.
Although, finite element method still remains most versatile, accurate and generally applicable technique for numerical analysis, the method is computationally expensive for wave propagation analysis of large structures. This is because for accurate prediction, the finite element size should be of the order of the wavelength, which is very small due to high frequency loading. Even in health monitoring studies, when the flaw sizes are very small (of the order of few hundred microns), only higher order modes will get affected. This
essentially leads to wave propagation problem. The requirement of costeffective computation of wave propagation brings us to the necessity of spectral finite element method, which is suitable for the study of wave propagation problems. By virtue of its domain transfer formulation, it bypasses the large system size of finite element method. Further, inverse problem such as force identification problem can be performed most conveniently and efficiently, compared to any other existing methods. In addition, spectral element approach helps us to perform force identification directly from the response histories measured in the sensor. The spectral finite element is used widely for both elementary and higher order one or two dimensional waveguides. Higher order waveguides, normally gives a behavior, where a damping mode (evanescent) will start propagating beyond a certain frequency called the cutoff frequency. Hence, when the loading frequencies are much beyond their corresponding cutoff frequencies, higher order mo des start propagating along
the structure and should be considered in the analysis of wave propagations.
Based on these considerations, three main goals are identified to be pursued in this
thesis. The first is to develop the constitutive relationship for magnetostrictive sensor and actuator suitable for structural analysis. The second is the development of different numerical tools for the modelling the damages. The third is the application of these developed elements towards solving inverse problems such as, material property identification, impact force identification, detection and identification of delamination in composite
structure.
The thesis consists of four parts spread over six chapters. In the first part, linear,
nonlinear, coupled and uncoupled constitutive relationships of magnetostrictive materials are studied and the elastic modulus and magnetostrictive constant are evaluated from the experimental results reported in the literature. In uncoupled model, magnetic field for actuator is considered as coil constant times coil current. The coupled model is studied without assuming any explicit direct relationship with magnetic field. In linear
coupled model, the elastic modulus, the permeability and magnetostrictive coupling are assumed as constant. In nonlinearcoupled model, the nonlinearity is decoupled and solved separately for the magnetic domain and mechanical domain using two nonlinear curves,’ namely the stress vs. strain curve and magnetic flux density vs. magnetic field curve. This is done by two different methods. In the first, the magnetic flux density is computed
iteratively, while in the second, artificial neural network is used, where a trained network gives the necessary strain and magnetic flux density for a given magnetic field and stress level.
In the second part, different finite element formulations for composite structures
with embedded magnetostrictive patches, which can act both as sensors and actuators,
is studied. Both mechanical and magnetic degrees of freedoms are considered in the
formulation. One, two and threedimensional finite element formulations for both coupled
and uncoupled analysis is developed. These developed elements are then used to identify
the errors in the overall response of the structure due to uncoupled assumption of the
magnetostrictive patches and shown that this error is comparable with the sensitivity
of the response due to different damage scenarios. These studies clearly bring out the requirement of coupled analysis for structural health monitoring when magnetostrictive sensor and actuator are used.
For the specific cases of beam elements, super convergent finite element formulation
for composite beam with embedded magnetostrictive patches is introduced for their specific advantages in having superior convergence and in addition, these elements are free from shear locking. A refined 2node beam element is derived based on classical and first order shear deformation theory for axialflexuralshear coupled deformation in asymmetrically stacked laminated composite beams with magnetostrictive patches. The element has an exact shape function matrix, which is derived by exactly solving the static part
of the governing equations of motion, where a general ply stacking is considered. This
makes the element super convergent for static analysis. The formulated consistent mass matrix, however, is approximate. Since the stiffness is exactly represented, the formulated element predicts natural frequency to greater level of accuracy with smaller discretization compared to other conventional finite elements. Finally, these elements are used for material property identification in conjunction with artificial neural network.
In the third part, frequency domain analysis is performed using spectrally formulated beam elements. The formulated elements consider deformation due to both shear
and lateral contraction, and numerical experiments are performed to highlight the higher order effects, especially at high frequencies. Spectral element is developed for modelling wave propagation in composite laminate in the presence of magnetostrictive patches. The element, by virtue of its frequency domain formulation, can analyze very large domain with nominal cost of computation and is suitable for studying wave propagation through composite materials. Further more, identification of impact force is performed form the
magnetostrictive sensor response histories using these spectral elements.
In the last part, different numerical examples for structural health monitoring are
directed towards studying the responses due to the presence of the delamination in the
structure; and the identification of the delamination from these responses using artificial neural network. Neural network is applied to get structural damage status from the finite element response using its mapping feature, which requires output uniqueness. To overcome the loss of output uniqueness due to the dimension reduction, damage space is divided into different overlapped zones and then different networks are trained for these zones. Committee machine is used to co ordinate among these networks. Next, a fivestage hierarchy of networks is used to consider partitioning of damage space, where different dimension reduction algorithms and different partitioning between training and
testing samples are used for better mapping fro the identification procedure. The results
of delamination detection for composite laminate show that the method developed in this thesis can be applied to structural damage detection and health monitoring for various industrial structures.
This thesis collectively addresses all aspects pertaining to the solution of inverse
problem and specially the health monitoring of composite structures using magnetostric
tive sensor and actuator. In addition, the thesis discusses the necessity of higher order theory in the high frequency analysis of wavw propagation. The thesis ends with brief summary of the tasks accomplished, significant contribution made to the literature and the future applications where the proposed methods addressed in this thesis can be applied. 
URI:  http://hdl.handle.net/2005/562 
Appears in Collections:  Aerospace Engineering (aero)

Items in etd@IISc are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.
